The Power of Story, Style, and Sisterhood in Boutique Retail

APPLE PODCAST | SPOTIFY | YOUTUBE

Ever wonder what it takes to turn a family passion into a thriving business? Join us as we chat with Kasey & Kaitlyn Widmyer, the dynamic duo behind Marmalade, a boutique inspired by their mother, Marie Widmeyer, and her fashion dreams. From childhood lessons to steering the business through the storms of the 2007-2008 recession, they share how these experiences crafted their resilience and work ethic. Get ready to be inspired as they recount their journey from playtime in the boutique aisles to orchestrating its expansion after college, proving that perseverance and adaptability can indeed breed success even in the most challenging economies.

The Power of Story, Style, and Sisterhood in Boutique Retail

Building a Boutique With Heart (and Candy!)

Marmalade’s foundation is deeply rooted in family. The sisters credit their mother for instilling a love of fashion, art, and business. She was the original creative visionary—known for her flair for merchandising and thoughtful storytelling through product curation.

One of Marmalade’s standout features is its iconic candy bar—yes, a real candy bar in every store. Inspired by childhood shopping trips to the mall, it adds a playful, nostalgic element to the shopping experience. Another unique touch is their “GRAB Bags,” a $5 surprise bag of leftover accessories. But it’s not just a fun clearance tactic—it’s a nod to their mom’s story of growing up in foster care. GRAB stands for Go, Reach, Achieve, Believe, and the bags are a tangible way to spread hope and inspiration.

Merchandising as a Storytelling Tool

Kasey and Kaitlyn see visual merchandising as an art form. They create frictionless experiences through styled racks that reflect real-life outfit pairings. The approach is less about minimalism and more about balance—chunky knits next to flowing fabrics, functional setups that invite customers to dig in and explore.

And while each Marmalade location has its own flair, there’s a shared thread of vintage decor, styled displays, and warmth that unifies the brand experience across all locations.

Scaling Without Losing the Soul

When asked about standardizing across locations, the sisters made it clear—they don’t aim to replicate; they aim to adapt. Each store reflects the spirit of its city, from Brooklyn’s fast-paced fashion to Savannah’s Southern charm. Still, technology like Lightspeed POS and weekly Google Doc reports help them stay aligned on business operations, customer experience, and sales performance.

Advice for Multi-Location Expansion

Thinking of opening a second (or third) store? Their advice:

Know your why—Are you expanding your customer base, or yourself as a business owner?
Use the right tools—Tech that allows seamless inventory transfers is key.
Hire for trust—If you’re not on-site, your store manager must share your vision.
Balance emotion with analysis—Keep the heart, but track the data.

Making the Jump Into Contemporary

Transitioning into higher price points was a thoughtful journey. One of their first leaps was bringing in Rails, a contemporary line with strong name recognition. They advise others to:

Start with well-known brands to build trust.
Focus on quality and longevity—especially with categories like denim.
Educate your customers—today’s shoppers value well-made, timeless pieces.

Lightning Round Lessons

Best use of time? Kasey says website listings; Kaitlyn would plan creative photo shoots.
Unsexy but essential? Inventory management and learning to manage team dynamics.
Hardest lesson? Avoid overbuying and emotionally driven decisions at market.
Best advice? “Don’t get too high on the highs or too low on the lows.”
Favorite metric? Margins and month-over-month growth—but with context!

A Legacy in the Making

When asked what they want to be remembered for 30 years from now, the sisters didn’t hesitate: staying true to themselves, embracing their femininity, and building a family-first business that makes people feel good. They’ve slowly grown more confident in sharing their personal stories and showing up on social media—not for vanity, but to connect.

As Ashley notes, “People don’t remember what they bought. They remember how you made them feel.” Marmalade is a beautiful example of heart-driven retail done right.

In This Episode

Kasey & Kaitlyn Widmyer (Marmalade): Instagram | Facebook | TikTok | Website
Join The Boutique Hub
Ashley Alderson: Instagram
The Boutique Hub: Website | Facebook | Instagram | Pinterest | TikTok | YouTube

Let’s Connect #AskAshley

Have a question or guest recommendation? Let us know your feedback directly here!
Do you love the Boutique Chat Podcast?! Subscribe to our podcast and after that, leave us a review on iTunes Apple Podcasts here!